Digitizing High-Touch Sales

Client
Varsity Tutors
Scope
Product Design
Platform
Timeframe
2025
Role
Senior Brand Experience Manager, Varsity Tutors

Turning a high-touch, phone-based tutoring sale into a self-serve digital experience that launched, with a projected $3M in annual savings.

Digitizing High-Touch Sales

In Q1 2025, Varsity Tutors set out to turn its high-touch, personalized sales process into a scalable digital experience without losing what made it work: precise student-tutor matching. I led the UX strategy and the cross-functional team that built it.

98%
of sales required telesales
$614
Customer acquisition cost
53%
of potential clients lost to process friction
The challenge

A sales process that didn't scale

Varsity Tutors' success came from understanding each student's needs through personal consultation. That came at a cost.

  • Existing process: three phone calls and two hours per client, an in-depth needs assessment by experienced consultants, $235 in sales costs per conversion, and a $614 customer acquisition cost.
  • Business constraints: limited scalability during peak seasons, 53% of potential clients lost to process friction, and unpredictable sales cycles that made staffing harder.

Lessons from the first ecommerce test

  • Return paths: PPC ads were the only way into the ecommerce pages, with no consistent path back from the homepage and little support for decisions made over several sessions.
  • Shared decisions: no way to share information with family members, an inconsistent experience between PPC landings and organic visits, and no clear way for returning visitors to find options they'd already viewed.
The approach

Solution design

The core sales experience

  • Student information: a step-by-step flow for academic goals, current challenges, subjects, grade level, and scheduling preferences.
  • Tutor matching: real-time tutor availability based on student needs, clear qualifications and experience, and immediate booking.

Better return paths

  • Multi-device continuity: Save Your Progress across devices, homepage content that adapts for returning visitors, and ecommerce access from every entry point.
  • Shared decision support: sharing features for family decision-making and a consistent experience across the site.
The business case

What the self-serve model was built to deliver

  • Grow ecommerce from 2% to 20% or more of sales, reducing reliance on telesales and saving an estimated $3M a year.
  • Improve lead conversion with a frictionless self-serve option.
  • Lower CAC to free budget for new acquisition channels.
  • Let the sales team focus on high-value leads with less staffing overhead.

The work translated human expertise into a digital format, keeping the value of personal consultation while supporting how families actually decide on educational services.

The result
Launched

The self-serve sales experience launched, with a projected $3M in annual savings as ecommerce grows from 2% to 20% or more of sales.

More stories of success

Turning Email Into a Revenue Engine
Plaid Crafts
February 1, 2026

Turning Email Into a Revenue Engine

Telling the Full Story of Every Trip
Mercy Medical Angels
January 15, 2026

Telling the Full Story of Every Trip

From Tasting Room to Trade
Barrel Oak Winery
January 1, 2026

From Tasting Room to Trade